Resources Relating the Impeachment Inquiry
Last updated 10.9.19 (Jump to new additions)
Last updated 10.9.19 (Jump to new additions)
Who are the main people involved in this story?
President of the United States and whose call to the Ukrainian President on July 25, 2019 initiated the whistle blower complaint and the current impeachment inquiry
President of Ukraine elected in April 2019. Ukraine was invaded by Russia in 2014. Russia has occupied or annexed parts of Ukrainian territory. The US has provided Ukraine with support to resist this invasion.
Attorney General of the United States under Donald Trump. The Attorney General is the Chief law enforcement officer of the US. He is not the President's private attorney.
Former mayor of New York City and currently the personal lawyer of Donal Trump. Giuliani has no official position within the US government.
The Secretary of State for the United States under Donald Trump
Former Vice-President of the United States under President Obama. Biden served as the administration's point man on Ukraine after the 2014 Russian invasion of Ukraine.
Joe Biden's son. Hunter Biden took a seat on the board of directors of the Ukrainian natural gas firm Burisma in April, 2014
The former prosecutor general of Ukraine
The Former US Special Envoy to Ukraine who served during the events of summer 2019. A career diplomat.*
Current US ambassador to the European Union. A political appointee*
Current US US chargé d'affaires to Ukraine. A career diplomat.*
The former US Ambassador to Ukraine from 2016-2019. She was dismissed from her post in May, 2019. In the July 25 phone call between president's Trump and Zelinsky, president Trump referred to her as "bad news." Yovanovitch is a career diplomat*
*The distinction between career officials and political appointees is made to distinguish between people who are career civil servants, and thus serve during the administrations of many different presidents, and political appointees, who are chosen to serve during the term of a specific president. Political appointees generally only serve in the administration in which they are appointed. This distinction is made across all departments in the federal bureaucracy. For example, scientists working for the Department of the Interior studying fire management are career officials, whereas the Secretary of the Interior is a political appointee.
Primary source documents
The Constitution establishes the legal basis for impeachment and removal. Relevant sections highlighted. The relevant passages are contained in Article I Section 2, Article I Section 3, Article II Section 4 and Article 3 Section 2.
The Intelligence Community’s Inspector General’s letter to Joseph Maguire (acting Director of National Intelligence) August 26, 2019. From the Politifact website.
This outlines the whistle blower’s complaint and the reasons the IG considered the issue and “urgent concern.”
A White House press release of the transcript of remarks made by the President during the week the whistelblower's complaint was released.
This is the phone call between President Trump and Ukrainian President Zelensky that is at the center of the whistle blower complaint.
The ICIG made this press release on September 30, 2019 to counter false claims made about the whistle blower and the whistle blower law.
Text messages between US and Ukrainian officials released by the Democratic leadership of the House Intelligence and Foreign Affairs Committees, October 4, 2019, reproduce in and annotated by the New York Times. (added 10.5.19)
A series of text messages exchanged by Bill Taylor (US chargé d'affaires to Ukraine), Gordon Sondland (US ambassador to the EU) and Kurt Volker (US Special Envoy to Ukraine) relating to issues relating to US Ukrainian relations.
White House Letter in Response to Impeachment Inquiry, October 8, 2019 (added 10.8.19)
A letter by Pat A. Cipollone, Counsel to the President, outlining reasons that the Trump administration will refuse to cooperate with the House impeachment inquiry.
Ousted ambassador Marie Yovanovitch tells Congress Trump pressured State Dept. to remove her, Washington Post, October 11, 2019 (added 10.14.19).
A news story about Marie Yovanovitch's testimony before the House Intelliegence Commitee on Friday, October 11, 2019.
Who Is Former U.S. Ambassador To Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch? Steve Inskeep, NPR, October 11, 2019 (added on 10.11.19).
An audio story on former Us Ambassador Maria Yovanovitch who was dismissed from her post last May By the Trump administration. Yovanovitch is set to testify before the House Intelligence committee on October 11, 2019. Steve Inskeep is a host of NPR's Morning Edition.
White House accuses Democrats of Trying to Overturn 2016 Election(audio story), NPR, October 10, 2019 (added 10.10.19)
NPR Morning Edition host Steve Inskeep speaks with Former George W. Bush Deputy White House Council Tim Flanigan about reasons for the White House's resistance to the impeachment inquiry. Whereas the previous two articles from the Washington Post and NPR explain why the White House resistance lacks legal merit, Flanigan defends the President's efforts.
Trump’s broad claims of executive immunity lead to criticism he is acting above the law , Toluse Olorunnipa and Ann E. Marimow, The Washington Post, October 9, 2109 (added 10.9.19).
An article in the Washington Post By the the paper's legal affairs and White House correspondents. The article examines and assesses the legal claims made in the President's refusal to cooperate with the House impeachment inquiry.
Fact Check: White House Legal Argument Against Impeachment Inquiry, Brian Naylor, NPR, October 9, 2019 (added 10.9.19).
This story interviews a number of legal scholars regarding the validity of the President's legal argument rejecting the impeachment inquiry. Brian Naylor is an NPR Washington DC correspondent.
White House Declares War on Impeachment Inquiry, Alleging Effort to Undo Trump’s Election, by Nicholas Fandos, Peter Baker and Michael S. Schmidt, New York Times, October 8, 2019 (added 10.8.19)
New York times story describing a letter sent to the Democratic leadership in Congress stating that the Trump administration would not comply with the impeachment inquiry, stating that it was "unconstitutional." For what the Constitution says about impeachment, see the highlighted parts of Articles I and II of the US Constitution.
Trump Denies Quid Peo Quo for Ukraine, but Envoys Had Their Doubts, Peter Baker, New York Times, October 4, 2019 (added 10.4.19)
An Article in the New York Times by Peter Baker, the Times' Chief White House correspondent. This article describes recently released text messages and the congressional testimony of Kurt Volker, former US special Envoy to Ukraine, that indicate American how career diplomats worried that the Trump administration was conditioning improved relations between the US and Ukraine on Ukraine's willingness to cooperate on matters relating to President Trump's requests made to President Zelensky during the July 25 telephone call.
'Atlantic': Prominent Americans Shouldn't Leverage Their Names For Payoffs, NPR, 10.3.19 (added 10.3.19)
An interview with Sarah Chayes critical of Hunter Biden's profiting off of the Biden name by taking a seat on the board of Burisma, the Ukrainian gas company. Chayes indicates that, while this practice is legal and quite common, is is a deeply problematic practice. Chayes is careful to distinguish between her criticism and the debunked accusations that the Joe Biden used his office as the Vice President to protect his son. Chayes is a former fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for Peace, a former advisor to the Joint Chiefs of Staff and a former reporter for NPR. The book referenced in this piece is titled Thieves of State: Why Corruption Threatens National Security
Lawfare Podcast on Ukraine (added 10.3.19)
This is an excellent background piece on Ukrainian politics and recent history. Probably one of the most useful resources I have found to put the events surrounding the impeachment inquiry into a Ukrainian context. Alina Polyakova is the Director of the Project on Global Democracy and Emerging Technology at the Brookings Institution.
What Trump and Zelensky said in their July 25 phone call, Jeanine Santucci, USA Today, September 25, 2019
This is a concise article summarizing the basic facts of the Ukraine call situations as of September 25, 2019. This is a good article to start with, but it offers little depth.
How to understand the Whistle blower Complaint, David Kris, Lawfare, September 27, 2019
This is a very long but useful article. It describes a chronology of events that led to the current situation an analysis of the facts of the situation and a road map of what likely will happen in the future (in terms of the impeachment process). The author is an attorney who served in the Department of Justice under both Republican and Democratic administrations.
Time line: Trump, Giuliani, Biden and Ukraingate (updated), Viola Gienger and Ryan Goodman, Just Security, September 24, 2019.
This is a story provides a comprehensive time line of events relating to the current situation including the actions of Hunter and Joe Biden, President Trump and Rudolph Giuliani. Gienger is a journalist and an expert on east European affairs. Goodman is the Editor in Chief of Just Security and is a professor of Law at New York University.
Trump and Giuliani’s Quest for Fake Ukraine “Dirt” on Biden: an Explainer, Viola Gienger, Just Security, September 10, 2019
This story explores the merits of the allegations made by the President against Joe Biden and his son Hunter.